The name easter island evokes a sense of mystery and romanticism. Feb 17, 2016 easter island is a great case of this kind of sociality in which populations seem to have mediated competition over limited resources through the community building of statues. This book employs the comparative method to understand societal collapses to which environmental problems contribute. Easter island, also known as rapa nui, is an island in the pacific famous for the massive humanoid statues peppered along its coasts. Diamond coined the term ecocide to describe this condition, which has happened to many civilizations throughout history, particularly that of the maya, who abandoned many of. Answers for what destroyed the civilisation of easter island. The author pursues the question why some societies collapsed and others didnt. Few places on earth are as well known for their socalled mysteries as easter island, also known as rapa nui. His chapter on easter island made me think of thor heyerdahls work there. Easter island is one of the most fragile environments in the polynesian islands.
Jun 10, 2019 diamond thinks these catastrophes led to a drop of perhaps onetenth of easter islands largest population. As jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by overexploiting its own resources. How societies choose to fail or succeed by jared diamond. Feb 09, 2005 the examples diamond cites where this has actually happened provide the grace notes to collapse moments when the book becomes less about failure and more about how a society might beat the. Jared diamonds thesis that easter island society collapsed in isolation. Diamond includes a number of wellknown classic cases of collapse from the past.
What are the main points of diamonds argument about. In 1995, science writer jared diamond popularized the collapse theory in a discover magazine. As jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by. Easter island books 101 books meet your next favorite book. In popular science literature, much ink has been spilled on the supposed collapse of easter island, or rapa nui, as its known in the local language jared diamonds 2005 book collapse, for. The islanders had migrated, perhaps accidentally, to a place with little water and fundamentally unproductive soil with. To research his new book, diamond traveled to the scenes of vanished societies like easter island, norse greenland, the. The big picture still looks like overexploitation, but when you get down into the details it does get messier, as not all the evidence marshalled to support the competing interpretations is strong enough to do so. Explore easter island rapa nui holidays and discover the best time and places to visit. In just a few centuries, the people of easter island wiped out their forest, drove their plants and animals to extinction, and saw their complex society spiral into chaos and cannibalism.
As no other phenomenon in living memory, the indian. Oct 31, 2011 the story of the ecocide and collapse of the civilization on easter island, or rapa nui in the native language, became very popular with the film rapa nui 1994 and the book by american. Join two intrepid young women as they delve into the centuriesold mysteries of easter island. In 2005, pulitzer winner jared diamond wrote the book on easter island. In 1995, unesco named easter island a world heritage site. Its hard to feel connected to chile, over 3700km to the east, let alone the wider world. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america.
Rather than a case of abject failure, the authors argue, rapa nui is an unlikely story of success. Diamond argues that the people of easter island essentially abused their environment. Kevin costner and easter island the easter island mystery is so intriguing, that a film has been made about it. Tensions between mainland chileans and islanders 118. Begin with an oceanic island fifteen hundred miles from any other landmass, one that had taken thousands of years for plant life to reach its shores and much longer before human life. Diamond felt as if he had entered a factory all of whose workers had suddenly quit for mysterious reasons. He has tramped the norse archaeological sites in greenland, and has visited iceland and easter island. They are linked by diamonds inquiry into what caused some of these societies such as the mayan civilisation or the people of easter island to. Collapse 2005 in this book jared diamond tells about the collapse of easter island, but also about several other cases of historical and modern societies who seemingly deliberately destroy the ecosystem they depend upon. Jared diamond, who used the easter island story as the lead case study in his 2005 book collapse, responds to the charge. If youre hoping to draw a line from easter island to our own struggles with climate change, this is your theory a handy blueprint for what happens when you fail to preserve your environment. The mysterious stone statues carved and erected by the rapa nui people have enthralled people since their discovery. The mystery of easter island travel smithsonian magazine.
An answer for an enduring question barzin pakandam abstract easter island is the most isolated inhabited spot on earth, devoid of heavy timber and most resources. Different pathways of tikopia and easter island tikopia island and easter island are. Aug, 2018 in popular science literature, much ink has been spilled on the supposed collapse of easter island, or rapa nui, as its known in the local language jared diamonds 2005 book collapse, for. Jared diamond described in its bestseller collapse the reasons for this ecoside. Easter island is a great case of this kind of sociality in which populations seem to have mediated competition over limited resources through the community building of statues. Diamond also shows clearly that poor leadership and greed by the ruling elite consistently results in disaster. The culture essentially selfdestructed, he asserts. This week i wrote a blog post reexamining the historical evidence for the view that what happened in prehistoric easter island is a classic story of ecological collapse and thereby holds lessons for us all. With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how if we see it in time.
Easter island, with an area of only 64 square miles, is the worlds most isolated scrap of habitable land. Diamond thinks these catastrophes led to a drop of perhaps onetenth of easter islands largest population. May 17, 2019 in 2005, pulitzer winner jared diamond wrote the book on easter island. How societies choose to fail or survive by jared diamond 400pp, allen lane. Easter islands end by jared diamond, in discover magazine august 1995. Scientists claim island civilisation didnt collapse the giant easter island stone heads may very well be. Similar problems face us today and have already brought disaster to rwanda and haiti, even as china and australia are trying to cope in innovative ways. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. Rethinking the fall of easter island american scientist. In his 2005 book collapse, diamond described rapa nui as the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by overexploiting its own resources. Jared diamond s argument about the society of easter island is laid out in chapter 2 of this book.
Easter island, also known as rapa nui, is a 63squaremile spot of land in the pacific ocean. The idea, popularized by scientist jared diamond in his book. Yet, the first european travellers to the island marvelled at large. I have mentioned easter island and norse greenland. Jo anne van tilburg is herself an archeologist who worked long years on easter island.
Jared diamond looks at several societies that have collapsed as a result of misusing their natural resources, plus a couple tokugawa period. Slowly unearthing the islands haunting past, they are forced to confront turbulent discoveries about themselves and the people they love, changing their lives forever. Dec 10, 20 as jared diamond tells it in his bestselling book, collapse, easter island is the clearest example of a society that destroyed itself by overexploiting its own resources. Easter island myths and realities canada free press. The myths of easter island jared diamond responds mark lynas. New evidence contradicts theory that easter island society. Jared diamond goes on to say, unlike the easter islanders, we have histories of the past information that can save us. As no other phenomenon in living memory, the indian ocean earthquake and resulting tsunami have reminded. Did easter islands inhabitants degrade their ecosystem to the point that the. It is a big, bold book but one that has drawn criticism from experts who dispute his theory, for example, of the demise of the indigenous people of easter island. Conflicting views of easter island by john flenley and paul bahn. Dec 26, 2011 in his chapter on easter island in the infamous book collapse, diamond finishes with this quote.
Diamond felt as if he had entered a factory all of whose workers had. Located 2,300 miles 3,700 km west of chile, easter island is one of the most remote places on earth. The mysteries of the easter island moai the agenda by. The meaning of easter island is that we must be aware of our impact on the environment, because once we destroy it we will be screwed. Easter island, a lesson for us all sustainable footprint. Score a book s total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book.
In the prologue, jared diamond summarizes his methodology in one paragraph. The myths of easter island jared diamond responds mark. Yet, the first european travellers to the island marvelled at large and delicately carved statues covering the whole of the island. By the time dutch explorersthe first europeans to reach the remote islandarrived on easter day in 1722, the land was nearly barren. Kristof, who may have gotten his easter island myths from jared diamonds misguided book collapse, demeans the sustainable traditions of the south pacifics polynesian settlers.
For a tiny island of 64 square miles, with its nearest neighbours some 1,300 miles. Aug, 2018 easter island, also known as rapa nui, is a 63squaremile spot of land in the pacific ocean. Diamonds examination of easter island once again demonstrates that culture cannot survive without nature. Jared diamonds argument about the society of easter island is laid out in chapter 2 of this book. Jared diamond, who used the easter island story as the lead case study in his 2005 book collapse, responds to the charge below. Apr 21, 2019 it is a big, bold book but one that has drawn criticism from experts who dispute his theory, for example, of the demise of the indigenous people of easter island. Oct 28, 2008 with lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how if we see it in time. This 77page guide for collapse by jared diamond includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 16 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. Scientists claim island civilisation didnt collapse the giant easter island stone heads may very well be a mystery lost to time but a team of scientists. Easter islanders weapons were deliberately not lethal. Among all such vanished civilizations that of the former polynesian society on easter island remain unsurpassed in mystery and isolation.
The chiefs of easter island, the ancient maya kings, and more recently the long, sorry list of corrupt rulers in haiti, rwanda, and other third world countries are examples. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. In his book, collapse, jared diamond wrote of the mountain from which easter islands moai were sculpted, no other site that i have visited made such a ghostly impression on me as rano raraku. In his 2005 book collapse, former national geographic explorerinresidence jared diamond characterizes the tools. From this brief and partial list it will be clear that not all the societies which diamond deals with have in fact collapsed to date. None of the popular moral lessons about easter island either in the hollywood movie or in diamonds book are true. People of easter island werent driven to warfare and. Few areas in the world possess a more mystical pull than this tiny speck of land, one of the most isolated places on earth. The story of the ecocide and collapse of the civilization on easter island, or rapa nui in the native language, became very popular with the film rapa nui 1994 and the book by american. Eight years ago jared diamond realized what is, for authors. The 66squaremile 170squarekilometer island was first inhabited by a group of pacific. Easter island s end by jared diamond, in discover magazine august 1995.
Easter island is most famous for its nearly 1,000 extant monumental statues, called moai, created by the early rapa nui people. The predominant aspects in diamonds ecocide hypothesis describe how a small group of colonists arrived on easter island around a. These moai are commonly called stone heads, but actually most possess bodies, and the largest constructed stands at over 30 feet and weighs 82 tons. Diamond says easter island provides the best historical example of a societal collapse in isolation.
What happened on easter island a new even scarier scenario. About 400 year ago a complete deforestation on easter island lead to a collapse of the easter society. The traditional explanation, detailed in paul bahn and john flenleys book easter island, earth island and later popularized by jared diamonds book collapse, describes an overzealous. We visited easter island in sept 2017 and have compiled this list of best easter island books for the curious traveler. In total questions, 2 questions are multiple choice form, 7 questions are matching headings form, 4 questions are summary, form completion form. The predominant aspects in diamond s ecocide hypothesis describe how a small group of colonists arrived on easter island around a. Diamond said that the islanders committed ecocide and touted easter island as an example of modern environmental problems. Was jared diamond right about the collapse of easter island. This book employs the comparative method to understand societal collapses to which.
1183 1489 422 1619 1260 153 103 1227 1202 712 311 1060 766 890 1418 673 335 867 1640 934 855 141 195 947 508 277 507 23 517 1513 913 1511 1318 1082 1082 991 1154 917 130 1455 1256